Tuesday, July 8, 2014

'The Tampa Bay Times endorsed Mitt Romney' (Updated)

This week a person argued on PolitiFact's Facebook page to the effect that PolitiFact isn't biased since the Tampa Bay Times endorsed Mitt Romney in the 2012 presidential election.

Of course the person had confused the Tampa Bay Times, which owns and runs PolitiFact, with the more conservative Tampa Tribune.  The Times endorsed Obama in 2012, just as it has endorsed Democratic candidates going back at least to 1948.

We don't think the editorial stance of the Times serves as a particularly good evidence of PolitiFact's liberal bias.  But it's worth burying once and for all the notion that the conservative editorial stance at the Times shows a lack of liberal bias at PolitiFact.

Without further ado, the documented evidence of the Times' support for Democratic presidential candidates going back to Truman:

The Tampa Bay Times (St. Petersburg Times) always endorses Democrats for president

2012:  Obama

Obama for president

2008:  Obama

The Times recommends: Obama for President

The Times doesn't make it easy to research its endorsements, so we have to rely on some secondary sources to round out our list.  Google's News Archive made the process perhaps easier than it's ever been.

2004:  Kerry

The St. Petersburg Times endorsed Kerry on Sunday

2000:  Gore

Gore for president

1996:  Clinton

1992:  Clinton

1988:  Dukakis

1984:  Mondale

1980:  Carter

1976:  Carter

1972:  McGovern

1968: Humphrey

1964: Johnson

The New York Times, Sept. 20, 1964:
ST. PETERSBURG, Fla., Sept. 19 (AP)—The St. Peters­burg Times endorsed Lyndon B. Johnson for the Presidency in its Sunday edition.

1960:  Kennedy

1956:  Stevenson

1952:  Stevenson

1948:  Truman

Update 7/11/2014:

The Times isn't as secretive about its endorsement history as we made it appear.  It's true that the Times' searchable archive makes individual endorsements hard to acquire, but the Times asked its editor of editorials and corporate board member Tim Nickens a question related to the subject back in 2010 (bold emphasis added). 
"While we have never recommended a Republican for governor or U.S. president, we have recommended Republicans in other statewide general elections for Cabinet."
That's a history of presidential elections dating back to the Times' origin back in 1884.

Maybe they endorse only Democrats to hide their deep conservative bias?


To our amusement, the comment falsely claiming the Times endorsed Romney received more Facebook "likes" than our reply (about 20 minutes later) showing the former claim false.

Thanks, discerning readers of PolitiFact!

1 comment:

  1. Wade Wilson, if you can express yourself without the profanity you'll have a better shot at getting published.


Thanks to commenters who refuse to honor various requests from the blog administrators, all comments are now moderated. Pseudonymous commenters who do not choose distinctive pseudonyms will not be published, period. No "Anonymous." No "Unknown." Etc.