"At PolitiFact, we wrote "Principles of the Truth-O-Meter" to help guide our work. Words matter was the first principle."
--Neil Brown, Poynter Institute President
"PolitiFact, thy name is Hypocrisy."
--PolitiFact Bias, longtime PolitiFact critics
What is a "handful"?
What is a "handful"? We could go to a dictionary for a definition. Or we could go to a higher source, such as the fact checkers at PolitiFact.
PolitiFact does the Youngkin handful
"Vaxxed and Relaxed" (@PorterPints) on March 1, 2022 highlighted a PolitiFact fact check of a "handful" claim made by Gov. Glenn Youngkin (R-Va.). Youngkin said Virginia is one of "a handful" of states that taxes veterans' retirement benefits.
In the text of the fact check, PolitiFact informs us that 12 out of 50 states is certainly more than a handful:
Virginia is one of three states that fully tax military pensions. Twelve more states tax the pensions at reduced rates, which is what Youngkin wants to do in Virginia.
All told, 15 states tax military pensions. That’s a minority, but certainly more than the "handful" Youngkin describes.
We rate Youngkin's claim Half True.
So, thanks to PolitiFact we know that the upper boundary for a "handful" is 12 or less, or perhaps 24% or less of a total if we use percentages.
PolitiFact does the Summers handful
Not long after "Vaxxed and Relaxxed" tweeted about the Youngkin "handful," we found another PolitiFact fact check of a "handful" claim, with this claim coming from Democrat Paul Summers.
Early in that year, two of the five incumbent Supreme Court justices stepped aside, reportedly after failing to gather enough political support among party activists on the Democratic Executive Committee. The Democratic nominees wound up being the only candidates on the ballot and were elected to full eight-year terms.
That was clearly a case where, as Summers states, a majority of the committee – 34 of the 66 members, or a "handful of party officials" if you will – was able to choose Supreme Court justices.
PolitiFact, then, has determined that a "handful" has an upper boundary of 14 or less and also an upper boundary no less than 34. Or, by percentage, an upper boundary of 24% and an upper boundary of no less than 51%.
In short, PolitiFact hilariously contradicted itself regarding the matter of the word "handful."
But just out of idle curiosity, what does the dictionary say?
Moral of the story
It's folly for a fact checker to try to place definite numerical boundaries around indefinite terms. Claims that include such terms serve as poor fact check fodder.
We note that Matt Palumbo somewhat pre-empted us on this story with a March 2, 2022 item. We will publish our version anyway, as the research locating the Simpson "handful" fact check was original with us. We're entitled to publish on the website the same comparison we made on Twitter on March 1, 2022.
Post a Comment
Thanks to commenters who refuse to honor various requests from the blog administrators, all comments are now moderated. Pseudonymous commenters who do not choose distinctive pseudonyms will not be published, period. No "Anonymous." No "Unknown." Etc.